• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

North Carolina Personal Injury & Workers Compensation Attorneys

  • facebook
  • twitter
  • instagram
  • linkedin

Call Us 919-240-4054

Main navigation

  • Camp Lejeune
  • Workers’ Comp
    • Durham, NC
      • Burns and Explosions
      • Durham back injury lawyers
      • Brain Injury
      • Chemical Exposure
      • Construction Accidents
      • Healthcare Workers and COVID-19
      • Occupational Disease
      • Union Members
      • Workplace Violence
  • Personal Injury
    • Durham, NC
      • Burn Injury
      • College Campus Injuries
      • Car Accidents
      • Catastrophic Injuries
      • Premises Liability
      • Product Liability
      • Trucking Accidents
      • Traumatic Brain Injury
    • Charlotte, NC
      • Trucking Accidents
      • Brain Injury Lawyer
      • Burn Injury Lawyer
      • Premises Liability Lawyer
      • Product Liability Lawyer
      • Car Accident Lawyer
      • Catastrophic Injury Lawyer
  • Wrongful Death
    • Durham, NC
    • Charlotte, NC
  • Bicycle Crash
    • Charlotte, NC
  • Our Lawyers
    • Ann E. Groninger
    • Valerie Johnson
    • Helen S. Baddour
    • Drew Culler
    • Jennifer Segnere
    • Speaking Engagements
  • Resources
    • Law Blog
    • Our Community
  • Contact Us
  • Español

July 20, 2014 By nicole

Court sides with worker who fell for unknown reason

To be entitled to workers’ compensation benefits in North Carolina for an arm injury, an injured worker needs to show that the injury was caused by an “accident”. If an employee injures his arm because of something that is an ordinary event, part of life for everyone, he is ordinarily not entitled to benefits.

Sometimes, however, people are injured, for example in a fall, and despite an investigation, no one can say for sure exactly what happened.  In those situations, our courts have developed the “unexplained fall”” doctrine. The doctrine says that if an employee falls and gets hurt, and no one can testify with necessary certainty why they fell, the worker is entitled to workers’ compensation benefits. In essence, the court say, where no one can say for sure exactly what happened, it’s the employer who should bear the burden of paying for the injury, rather than the worker. The reason is that the Workers’ Compensation Act was set up as a system where industry pays for its damage. The system takes away an injured worker’s right to sue the employer, in exchange for giving the employer the burden of providing benefits in most situations where workers are injured.

In Philbeck v. University of Michigan, decided last week, the Court of Appeals applied the “unexplained fall” doctrine in a case where a 67-year old woman who traveled as part of her job fell while walking to her car, and broke her arm. The woman didn’t know what had caused her to fall, and although several doctors testified that she could have been dehydrated, they could not say to a  reasonable degree of medical certainty that dehydration had caused the fall. As a result of the opinion the employer is responsible for paying the woman’s medical bills and for paying her weekly workers’ compensation benefits while she heals from the injury.

Filed Under: Work Injury, Workers' Compensation Tagged With: arm injury, NC Industrial Commission, workers compensation

Primary Sidebar

Primary Sidebar

Occupation

  • Bus Drivers
  • Construction Workers
  • First Responders
  • Police Officers
  • Truck Drivers
  • State Employees
  • Union Members

Injury

  • Asbestos Exposure
  • Durham back injury lawyers
  • Brain Injury
  • Burns and explosions
  • Chemical Exposure
  • COVID-19 and Healthcare Workers
  • Occupational Diseases
  • Workplace Violence

Free Legal Resources

  • Workers’ Compensation 101
  • 8 Questions to Answer Before You Are Ever in a Wreck
  • Essentials for Workers’ Comp Success
  • Help for Families of North Carolina Burn Victims

Locations

Durham Office

300 Blackwell St S#101, Durham, NC 27701

Phone: (919) 240-4054

Fax: (888) 412-0421

Charlotte Office

1018 East Blvd., Ste 6 Charlotte, NC 28203

Phone: (704) 200-2009

Fax : (888) 412-0421

Read Our Google Reviews

Get more stuff

Subscribe to our mailing list and get interesting stuff and updates to your email inbox.

Thank you for subscribing.

Something went wrong.

We respect your privacy and take protecting it seriously.

Copyright Johnson & Groninger PLLC Law Firm SEO by EverSpark Interactive