• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

North Carolina Personal Injury & Workers Compensation Attorneys

  • facebook
  • twitter
  • instagram
  • linkedin

Call Us 919-240-4054

Main navigation

  • Workers’ Comp
    • Durham, NC
      • Brain Injury Lawyer
      • Burns and Explosions Lawyer
      • Chemical Exposure Lawyer
      • Construction Accident Lawyer
      • Durham Back Injury Lawyer
      • Healthcare Workers and COVID-19 Lawyer
      • Occupational Disease Lawyer
      • Union Member Lawyer
      • Workplace Violence Lawyer
    • Charlotte, NC
  • Bicycle Crashes
    • Charlotte, NC
  • Personal Injury
    • Durham, NC
      • Burn Injury Lawyer
      • College Campus Injury Lawyer
      • Car Accident Lawyer
      • Catastrophic Injury Lawyer
      • Motorcycle Accident Lawyer
      • Premises Liability Lawyer
      • Product Liability Lawyer
      • Truck Accident Lawyer
    • Charlotte, NC
      • Brain Injury Lawyer
      • Burn Injury Lawyer
      • Car Accident Lawyer
      • Catastrophic Injury Lawyer
      • Premises Liability Lawyer
      • Motorcycle Accident Lawyer
      • Product Liability Lawyer
      • Truck Accident Lawyer
  • Wrongful Death
    • Durham, NC
    • Charlotte, NC
  • Our Lawyers
    • Ann Groninger
    • Valerie Johnson
    • Drew Culler
    • Jennifer Segnere
    • Request a Speaking Engagement
  • Resources
    • Law Blog
    • Our Community
  • Contact Us
  • Español

July 30, 2018 By nicole

Planning to Settle Your Workers Compensation Case Without a Lawyer? Beware.

Table of Contents

Toggle
  • Why You Should Use a Lawyer to Settle Workers Compensation
    • Related posts:
Planning to Settle Your Workers Compensation Case Without a Lawyer? Beware. 1

Why You Should Use a Lawyer to Settle Workers Compensation

Thinking you can save a few bucks by settling your workers comp case without a lawyer?  Buyer beware!  The North Carolina Court of Appeals reminds us in Ramirez v. Stuart Pierce Farms (June 5, 2018, Elmore, J., unpublished) that a workers’ compensation settlement is final, even when the injured worker settled without an attorney and later discovered he may have reached a higher settlement if he had retained counsel. In Ramirez, the injured worker did not speak or write English and was not represented by counsel when he entered into a $20,000.00 settlement. Four years later, he retained an attorney who tried to reopen his case, claiming that the settlement was not fair because the deputy commissioner who approved the settlement did not have all the medical records at the time of approval. Mr. Ramirez served a subpoena on the deputy commissioner who had approved his settlement, but the Industrial Commission and Court of Appeals both held that the subpoena should be quashed, because the deputy commissioner did not need to testify. The courts found no evidence of fraud, misrepresentation, mutual mistake, or undue influence, so nothing could be done. Too bad, so sad.

It is only natural for injured workers, once they start feeling better, to want to close out their case, especially when they receive that settlement offer from the insurance company. Who doesn’t want money, right?  Unfortunately, some injured workers wrongly believe that, because their workers’ compensation settlement agreement must be reviewed and approved by a deputy commissioner at the Industrial Commission, someone knowledgeable is looking out for their legal interests. While the Industrial Commission rules do require the assigned deputy commissioner to make sure the agreement contains all the required language so that it is “fair and just to all parties,” the deputy commissioner is not allowed to represent the injured worker or fight for his interests over the interests of the insurance company. The deputy commissioner only addresses the information presented to him or her, and many unrepresented workers simply do not know enough about the Workers’ Compensation Act to know how to present their best case. The Workers’ Compensation Act contains more than 56,000 words, and that does not even include the 112 pages of interpreting rules and hundreds more interpreting appellate cases. Even the most educated and diligent injured worker cannot expect to read all that law, much less apply it effectively to his or her case.

For example, injured workers usually do not know the law allows them to request a second opinion disability rating from a doctor of their own choice, and the insurance adjuster, naturally, rarely offers up that option…why would she? Sadly, many unrepresented workers settle without ever obtaining that vital second opinion, which can greatly increase the settlement value of the case.

In the case of Mr. Ramirez, because he was not represented by an attorney, he did not know one other nuance of the law which allowed him to include certain medical records with his settlement agreement package. Even though he made that mistake when he settled, the courts found that the deputy commissioner had enough information to approve the settlement four years earlier.

The lesson for injured workers? The stakes are high when entering into a workers’ compensation settlement, so be very careful if you are unrepresented. Even if you find out later that the settlement was insufficient or unfair, most likely your options will be limited. Get it right the first time.

The experienced litigation attorneys at Johnson & Groninger PLLC regularly represent injured workers in workers’ compensation matters and are concerned about injured workers who try to represent themselves without legal counsel. If you have a friend or family member is thinking of reaching a workers’ compensation settlement without an attorney, contact one of the experienced attorneys at Johnson & Groninger for a personal consultation. 

 

Related posts:

  1. Valerie speaks at 2008 AFL-CIO LCC conference on protecting injured workers
  2. Fourth Circuit reverses the Board in Longshoreman Act case
  3. Court of Appeals rules attendant care services compensable without pre-approval
  4. Report finds both workers and doctors pressured to avoid reporting workplace injuries

Filed Under: Work Injury, Workers' Compensation

Primary Sidebar

Primary Sidebar

Contact us

Occupation

  • Bus Drivers
  • Construction Workers
  • First Responders
  • Police Officers
  • Truck Drivers
  • State Employees Workers’ Compensation Lawyers in Charlotte
  • Experienced Union Members Attorneys in North Carolina

Injury

  • Asbestos Exposure
  • Durham Back Injury Lawyers
  • Burns and explosions
  • Chemical Exposure
  • COVID-19 and Healthcare Workers
  • Occupational Diseases
  • Workplace Violence

Free Legal Resources

  • Workers’ Compensation 101
  • 8 Questions to Answer Before You Are Ever in a Wreck
  • Essentials for Workers’ Comp Success
  • Help for Families of North Carolina Burn Victims

Locations

Durham Office

300 Blackwell St. #101,
Durham, NC 27701

Phone: (919) 240-4054

Fax: (888) 412-0421

Charlotte Office

1018 East Blvd. #6
Charlotte, NC 28203

Phone: (704) 200-2009

Fax : (888) 412-0421

Practice Areas

Workers Compensation | Bicycle Crashes | Personal Injury

OTHER PRACTICE AREAS

Crisis Management | Employment Law | Mass Torts | Camp Lejeune Water Contamination | Vaccine Injury | Resort & Recreational Activity Injuries | Workers Comp Wage & Hours Disputes | College Campus Injuries | Drunk Driving Injury victim | Industrial Accidents | Inadequate Security Claims | Workplace Injuries | Covid 19 – Business Interruption | Workplace Injury 3rd Party Claims

Copyright Johnson & Groninger PLLC